New TFC Research: Eraser is Made of Plastic And Can Be Toxic to Children

2020/4/23 18:05:37

Press Release

[April 23, 2020] While many parts of the world are still in throes of COVID-19, many Chinese schools have been resuming classes as the epidemic looses its grip on China. For Chinese parents, however, aside from the deadly pandemic caused by a novel coronavirus, they may have to have at least one more concern for their children - the eraser.

As Shenzhen-headquartered NGO Toxics-Free Corps found in a recent investigation, many of the erasers in the market on Chinese mainland contain toxic substance that could pose potential hazards to children’s health.

The collected eraser samples come from the three E-commerce platforms including Taobao, Jingdong and Pinduoduo, as well as the on-site purchase of offline stores, with a total of 86 items, involving 33 well-known stationery brands.

Among 62 erasers the NGO sent for testing, 21 were found containing phthalic acid esters (PAEs), a kind of plasticizer. Moreover, the content of the substance in 18 ones go beyond a well-known voluntary standard issued by China Stationery & Sporting Goods Association, the NGO said.

In one of the erasers, the content is 913 times higher than the standard, it added.

For juveniles, PAEs could cause damages to the liver and kidney and may also result in sexual precocity. The substance could also affect female reproductive health and increase breast cancer risk for women. What’s more, birth defects may occur because of pregnant women’s exposure to it.

Xu Shan, a chief physician from Hangzhou Amcare Women’s and Children’s Hospital in Zhejiang provincial capital Hangzhou, said the safety hazards from PAEs have been verified both in experiments and clinical big data analysis.

Experiments done on animals home and abroad have shown that, if animals intake the substance for an extended period of time, their reproductive capabilities will be damaged and there will also be higher occurrence of birth defects, he said.

He said clinical analysis using big data technology also found that the increasing incidence of hypospadias for newborn baby boys and the continuous decline of female reproductive capability are related to the accumulation of plasticizer in the environment.

He calls the authorities to draft relevant laws as soon as possible to restrict the use of PAEs to protect people’s health.

Mao Da, executive director of Toxics-Free Corps, said the lack of compulsory standard for chemical contents is one of the factors to blame for the excessive amount of PAEs in erasers.

The latest industrial standard for students' supply was made public in 2007 and there has been no update to the standard thereafter. The standard doesn’t include any limits on some toxic substances such as PAEs, he noted.

The substance is also absent from a 2010 industrial standard for eraser, he continued.

Ms Wen Ruihuan, the manager of the campaign added that the toxic chemical problem of eraser was closely link to the polyvinyl chloride (PVC) plastic material use, because half of the 86 samples are PVC products, and all samples that contain PAEs are PVC based. She therefore alerted that consumer need to avoid buying PVC erasers while paying attention to the labelling information of the products.

By the day of this release is being made, Toxic-Free Corps has received two contrasting official responses from two Japanese eraser producers respectively. UNI replied the earliest and made clear commitment to voluntarily stopping selling all products which phthalate content exceeds China’s industry group standard limit. KOKUYO, on the contrary, refused to take NGO’s suggestion and emphasized that their products still complied with all Chinese regulation.


Report Abstract

A Material and Toxic Plasticizer Survey of 86 Kinds of Eraser Product in the Market

In March 2020, in order to reduce the impact of toxic plasticizer exposure on students' health, Toxics-Free Corps launched a systematic product safety market survey for eraser, an important category of stationery. The eraser samples collected in the survey come from the three E-commerce platforms including Taobao, Jingdong and Pinduoduo, as well as the on-site purchase of offline stores, with a total of 86 items, involving 33 well-known stationery brands. The investigators first used XRF analyzer to analyze the materials of all 86 kinds of eraser samples, and then sent 62 of them to a qualified third-party laboratory to test the content of 6 kinds of phthalic acid esters (PAEs).

Main conclusions:

[1] In all 62 eraser samples, the detection rate of PAEs is 34%, the exceeding rate for industry group standard is 29%, the average PAEs level of exceeding samples is 361 times the standard limit, and the maximum level is 913 times the limit, which indicates that the problem of toxic plasticizer of eraser products is really serious, which may pose a higher health risk to users, especially young children.

[2] All eraser samples with phthalate detected or exceeding the standard are made of PVC, which indicates that PVC eraser has higher risk of toxic plasticizer exposure than non PVC eraser.

[3] The rate of effective labelling or information disclosure of the material and chemical use of the eraser samples is less than 30%, which indicates that the consumers' right to know about the quality and safety of the eraser products is not guaranteed as a whole.

[4] The current national standards or industry recommended standards for erasers are seriously deficient in the control of toxic plasticizers, which makes such products still unable to get rid of the pollution of phthalate, a chemical with high environmental health risk; the industry association group standard with the content of 6 kinds of phthalate limit has advocacy and leading role in the green production of eraser products, but it is note able to achieve the total phase-out of PAEs and PVCs use in eraser production.

[5] Some eraser samples sold by E-commerce are inconsistent with the test results of the same type of products sold from flagship stores or exclusive stores of the brand, which indicates that there may be counterfeiting products, which needs to be noticed by relevant parties.

Main suggestions:

[1] Consumers have priority in purchasing non-phthalate plasticizers and non PVC erasers. When purchasing, please refer to the "white list" given in this survey. Parents should pay attention to whether children have the habit of licking, sucking and chewing stationery. If there is such a situation, please correct it immediately.

[2] Stationery manufacturers actively follow the industry group standard TCSSGA 1002-2017 "Eraser" and the national standard GB 21027-201x "General requirements for the safety of student supplies (Draft for approval)", to ensure that phthalate plasticizers do not exceed the standard. At the same time, formulate a schedule for PVC phase-out and non-toxic substitution of eraser products, and make relevant plans public.

[3] National Professional Standardization Techniques Commission shall complete the revision of GB 21027-2007 General requirements for the safety of student supplies as soon as possible, and add the limit provisions for toxic and harmful chemicals such as phthalates and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.

[4] The Ministry of Ecology and Environment comprehensively assessed the chemicals with high risks to the ecological environment and public health, including phthalates, and listed them in the list of priority controlled chemicals as soon as possible, so as to control the toxic and harmful chemicals from the source.

[5] E-commerce platforms shall strengthen shop qualification verification and product quality monitoring to prevent fake and substandard products from entering the platform; at the same time, platform registered shops shall actively publish product safety information of erasers and other children's toys and stationery, especially chemical safety information.

[6] All parties work together to promote the safety standards of eraser and other student supplies, promote brand makers and manufacturers to follow the industry's high standards, advocate the public to buy safety products, and better protect the health of young children and the public.

Report Dowloading:A Material and Toxic Plasticizer Survey of 86 Kinds of Eraser Product in the Market (Chinese)